I'm new here, so please forgive me if this has been covered already...
I've clicked on the FAQ link and got to a 404 page

You should really fix that, the site is a bit mysterious for newcomers, especially the fact that there is this forum and the audiopolis.org front site... I'm not quite clear what the relation is between the two...
First off, I really like the idea of this site, and the review process in general. I'm coming from another forum, where we very often review peer songs (openly), but with a focus on audio engineering mostly (although advice on arrangement are often given as well). The songs are not finished yet and the OP is usually asking for advice on the mix. This one is different and quite cool as well.
Your site sounds like a great idea and your blind review system is very well thought of.
I just reviewed a dozen+ songs to get a feel of it, and so far I find the process rather interesting...
2 questions/comments though:
- I didn't see any way to comment on a song that you are listening to. As much as the blind review is a great thing, I think being able to review a song you like would be beneficial as well: imagine I listen to a new song posted, and I like what I hear, but I also have some suggestions (either production or arrangement, or anything that could help the poster), I see no way of doing that... Or am I missing something?
- The blind review system doesn't tell me the name of the song, nor can I see the lyrics. I think that would help.
English is not my main language and I often like to read the lyrics of songs I don't know. Otherwise I might be missing a bit. A simple link to the lyrics (when they are provided) could be a good thing IMHO. Especially since one of the free criteria is 'lyrics'. I wouldn't be able to rate that confidently without being able to read them, I'm afraid...
Anyway, that's just 2 little things that I thought of while going through the review process.
It looks like a nice community and I look forward to be part of it.
Keep it up!
-Patrick